Brown Pelican Society Contact the Brown Pelican Society Commentary About

Post details: JUSTICE JOHN ROBERTS - "THE WAY TO STOP DISCRIMINATION ON THE BASIS OF RACE IS TO STOP DISCRIMINATING ON THE BASIS OF RACE"

Permalink 05:48:09 am, by scribe Email , 564 words,   English (US)
Categories: Commentary

JUSTICE JOHN ROBERTS - "THE WAY TO STOP DISCRIMINATION ON THE BASIS OF RACE IS TO STOP DISCRIMINATING ON THE BASIS OF RACE"

.........Justices Reject School Integration Efforts....The decision, coming on the last day of this year's term, highlighted the fact that a conservative bloc led by Roberts prevailed in nearly all of the major cases that came before the court. On abortion, religion, campaign finance and now school integration, the chief justice has put together a five-member majority to move the law to the right.......

David Savage, Los Angeles Times, (FIDELIS), 06-29-2007

In a decision that may herald a new era in the long struggle over racial integration in public education, the Supreme Court declared Thursday that officials may not use race to assign children to schools, even if the goal is greater diversity.

Neither white nor black students may be turned away from a particular school simply because of their race, the court said in a 5-4 decision.

The decision opens the door to legal challenges to integration strategies that have been adopted in school systems across the country, including Los Angeles Unified School District — strategies that limit the number of white and minority students who may attend particular schools.

Thursday's ruling did not directly address any programs other than the Seattle and Louisville, Ky., policies before the court, but the language of the majority opinion suggested others could face close scrutiny.

"The way to stop discrimination on the basis of race is to stop discriminating on the basis of race," Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. wrote in the majority opinion. Public schools must "stop assigning students on a racial basis," he said.

Some lawyers following the case said the ruling could spell trouble for racial guidelines in as many as 1,000 school districts across the nation. But each district's program differs, and it is unclear how sweeping the effect of Thursday's ruling will be.

The ruling also raised questions about how the high court, with its conservative bloc strengthened by the addition of Roberts as chief justice in 2005, will deal with the legacy of the landmark Brown vs. Board of Education decision that ignited half a century of struggle over busing and other efforts to promote racial integration in schools.

The decision, coming on the last day of this year's term, highlighted the fact that a conservative bloc led by Roberts prevailed in nearly all of the major cases that came before the court. On abortion, religion, campaign finance and now school integration, the chief justice has put together a five-member majority to move the law to the right.

Roberts cited the decision in Brown in support of his opinion in the current case. Just as Brown struck down forced segregation nationwide, he said, the court is now declaring that students may not be classified "based on the color of their skin."

The court's four liberal justices accused the majority of turning its back on Brown and the promise of racial integration.

"This is a decision that the court and the nation will come to regret," Justice Stephen G. Breyer said in a long dissent delivered in the courtroom...."It is not often so few have quickly changed so much," he said at one point.

In a separate dissent, 87-year-old Justice John Paul Stevens noted how far the court had moved in his long tenure. "It is my firm conviction that no member of the court that I joined in 1975 would have agreed with today's decision," he wrote.
........TO CONTINUE READING ARTICLE, CLICK ON TITLE........

Permalink

Comments:

No Comments for this post yet...

Brown Pelican Society Commentary

Thank you for visiting the Brown Pelican Society of Louisiana! You're on the Commentary page. To view our Scorecard, click the button on the menu above.

The Brown Pelican Society of Louisiana is a non-profit 501(c)(3) lay Catholic organization, dedicated to educating the public on pro-life issues before the Louisiana Legislature.

Support the Brown Pelican!
Now you can support your favorite non-profit, The Brown Pelican Society!  Click the tax-deductible donation amount you would like to give in the drop-down box below and then click "Checkout" on the button below. 

The Brown Pelican Society of Louisiana thanks you for your support!

If you would like to mail in a donation, send it to:
The Brown Pelican Society
5740 Citrus Boulevard
Suite 102
Harahan, Louisiana 70123

 
January 2009
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
<< <     
        1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30 31

Search

Misc

Syndicate this information XML

What is RSS?

Who's Online?

Guest Users: 11