‘The Great Scattering’: How Identity Panic Took Root in the Void Once Occupied by Family Life, by Mary Eberstadt

Fr. Matthew P. Schneider: Assisted Suicide: How the Church Should Behave and WHY
August 29, 2019
The Real War on Women, by Stan Guthrie
August 29, 2019

Featured image: The family of Ole Hanson (1874-1940), a mayor of Seattle and the founder of San Clemente, CA.

By Mary Eberstadt, Quillette, August 27, 2019

Of all the issues that divide us, none seems as inimical to reasoned discussion as identity politics. Conservatives excoriate such politics as politically opportunistic theater, the acting out of coddled “snowflake” students. Liberals and progressives put forth an opposing grievance-first narrative, arguing that identity politics emanates from authentic wounds.

But what if both contenders have a piece of the truth? What if many identity-firsters today are claiming to be victims because they and their societies are victims—only not so much of the abstract “isms” they denounce, but of something else that till now has eluded description?

Let’s try a new theory: Our macro-politics have become a mania about identity because our micropolitics are no longer familial. This, above all, is what happened during the decades in which identity politics went from being a phrase in an obscure quasi-radical document to a way of being that has gone on to transform academia, law, media, culture and government.

Yes, racism, sexism and other forms of cruelty exist, and are always to be deplored and countered. At the same time, the timeline of identity politics suggest another source. Up until the middle of the twentieth century (and barring the frequent foreshortening of life by disease or nature) human expectations remained largely the same throughout the ages: that one would grow up to have children and a family; that parents and siblings and extended family would remain one’s primal community; and that, conversely, it was a tragedy not to be part of a family. The post-1960s order of sexual consumerism has upended every one of these expectations. ….

Read more at  https://quillette.com