CNA: Does Vatican’s Decision on Jesuit Prep School Undermine Indianapolis’ Archbishop?

CNA: Leading American Catholic Philosophers Say JPII Institute Changes Threaten Credibility
September 26, 2019
Trump to UN: No Global Right to Abortion, by David Nussman
September 26, 2019

Brebeuf Jesuit Preparatory School

ANALYSIS: The canonical realities of the case don’t support most of the conjecture.

By J.D. Flynn, CNA, 9/25/19

INDIANAPOLIS — Brebeuf Jesuit Preparatory School in Indianapolis announced this week that the Vatican’s Congregation for Catholic Education has suspended a decree prohibiting the school from calling itself Catholic.

The announcement has led to speculation and debate about the likely outcome for an appeal filed against the decree. But the canonical realities of the case don’t support most of the conjecture.

The decree was issued by Archbishop Charles Thompson, after a disagreement between the Archdiocese of Indianapolis and the school over the employment of a teacher in a same-sex union. It was appealed by the Jesuit province that oversees the school.

To some Catholics, the Vatican’s decision to suspend the decree, and its eventual decision on the Jesuit’s appeal, seems to be a referendum on whether the Church’s hierarchy will defend its teaching on homosexuality. But the case is more complicated than that, and commentators reducing it to a battle over doctrine could lead Catholics into serious confusion.

In June, Archbishop Thompson announced that Brebeuf could no longer call itself Catholic after two years of talks between the school and the archdiocese broke down. The issue began when the archdiocese became aware that a teacher had entered into a same-sex “marriage,” and requested that the school not renew the teacher’s contract. ….