CNSNews: IVF and Frozen Embryos: What Should We Do with These Little Abandoned Lives?

One Year After PA Grand Jury Report, States Continue Probes of Clergy Abuse, Cover-Ups, by Lauretta Brown
August 23, 2019
The Glendon Commission, by David Carlin
August 23, 2019

3D rendering of the icsi(intracytoplasmic sperm injection) process - in which a single sperm is injected directly into an egg 653378396 ivf, icsi, fertility, sperm cells, spermium, egg cell, embryo, insemination, pregnancy, treatment, human, clinic, medical, needle, male, female, reproductive, lab, 3d, rendering

By John Stonestreet and G. Shane Morris, CNSNews, August 22, 2019

John StonestreetG. Shane MorrisI’m unapologetically Protestant but, as I’ve said for a while now, our Catholic friends have long led the way on many bioethical issues like abortion and assisted reproductive technologies. For example, back in 2008, the Vatican released a document called “Dignitatis personae,” which said that “The desire for a child, while good, cannot justify the ‘production’ of offspring, just as the desire to not have a child cannot justify the abandonment or destruction of a child once he or she has been conceived.”

Now, I recognize that Christians disagree about whether it’s intrinsically wrong to conceive children outside of the sexual union of husband and wife, including in vitro fertilization. Because God ordered the pleasure and intimacy of married sex toward procreation, I find the Catholic ethical teaching against IVF to be compelling.

Still, like I said, not all Christians agree. For example, several months ago, I had a robust discussion on this issue on the BreakPoint Podcast with my friend Dr. David Stevens. David has long led the Christian Medical and Dental Society and has been one of the great medical missionaries of our lifetime.

What David and I did agree on, and what everyone should agree on (especially Christians), is that any fertility process that knowingly destroys or abandons human lives—including embryos—is immoral. And that’s what the debate over IVF must confront right now. ….