The Theological Illiteracy of “Dare We Hope?”, by Clement Harrold

Joe Biden Cancels Declaration Trump Signed With 34 Nations Saying There’s No Right to Abortion, by Lisa Correnti
May 6, 2021
St. John Paul II on the Joy in Finding Meaning in Suffering. by Paul Chaloux
May 6, 2021

[Photo Credit: Balthasar & Speyr/Catholic Distance University]

By Clement Harrold, Crisis Magazine, May 6, 2021

Clement Harrold is a British citizen studying at the Franciscan University of Steubenville, majoring in Theology, Philosophy, and Classics, with a minor in German.

Clement HarroldIt has rightly been said that in order to appreciate the “Good News” of salvation we first need to recognize the bad news of damnation. This point appears to have been lost on the likes of Bishop Robert Barron with his echoing of 20th century Swiss theologian Hans Urs von Balthasar’s suggestion that we might reasonably hope that all men are saved. In a recent Sunday sermon, Barron is careful to affirm that the “fullness of salvation” lies in Jesus alone, yet he immediately follows this with the observation that all the other major religions of the world can participate in this salvation offered by Christ.

The case which Barron develops is made on the basis of Lumen Gentium 16, as well as John Henry Newman’s description of conscience as the “aboriginal vicar of Christ in the soul.” What the good bishop neglects to mention, however, is that this same John Henry Newman was deeply pessimistic about the eternal prospects of those outside the Church. Like Augustine, Newman felt compelled on the basis of Scripture to believe in the massa damnata, a position which takes literally Christ’s words that only few will enter the gate to eternal life (see Matthew 7:1). …