Analysis: US Bishops at Odds Over Abortion and ‘The Francis Test’, Ed Condon

Does Pope’s Representative Hope to Silence US Bishops’ Questions? by Phil Lawler
November 13, 2019
‘My Life Was a Miracle’: The Journey of an Abortion Survivor, by Katrina Trinko
November 13, 2019

The USCCB autumn general assembly in Baltimore, Md., Nov. 11, 2019. Credit: Christine Rousselle/CNA.

By Ed Condon, CNA, Nov. 12, 2019

– During the second day of the USCCB Fall General Assembly in Baltimore, divisions among the bishops bubbled briefly to the surface, with bishops exchanging sharp interventions on the “preeminence’ of abortion as a social concern.
The exchanges highlighted simmering tensions among the bishops, which have less to do with the centrality of abortion to the Church’s political engagement, and more to do with bishops contending to appear closer to the pope than their colleagues.

Cracks in the conference appeared as the bishops discussed amendments to a letter meant to accompany a series of videos aimed at helping Catholics engage with the American political process when Cardinal Blase Cupich of Chicago asked for a separate consideration of one of the amendments.

The cardinal suggested the insertion of a long paragraph into the text which would contextualize the Church’s position on life issues, and especially the teaching of Pope Francis.  ….