Faith, Certainty, and Doubt, by Randall Smith

Vatican Press Office: Francis Calls for ‘Drastic’ and ‘Intense’ Action on Environment
November 28, 2023
EXCLUSIVE: Strickland Sacking Signals ‘Internal Persecution of Faithful Catholics by the Pope’, by Simon Caldwell
November 28, 2023

*Image: The Rescue by Honoré Daumier, c. 1870 [Hamburgeer Kunsthalle, Hamburg, Germany]

By Randall Smith, The Catholic Thing, Nov. 28, 2023

Randall B. Smith is a Professor of Theology at the University of St. Thomas in Houston, Texas. His latest book is From Here to Eternity: Reflections on Death, Immortality, and the Resurrection of the Body.

Note: Today is “Giving Tuesday.” At The Catholic Thing, we don’t go in much for these new-fangled secular holy days. There’s nothing wrong with giving — if you know what you’re giving TO of course. If you’re reading this, I’m sure you already know that donating to the work of TCT has some quite definite purposes. It’s all AMDG here, all the time. So whether you believe it’s a special day today or not, we believe all days are, under God, special days. Help us to make 2024 special for the Church and the world by bringing this end-of-year fundraising to a great close. Click the button. Give, generously. – Robert Royal   

Are you certain God exists?  Are you certain He doesn’t?  Who has the burden of proof here?  Should believers have to prove that God exists? Or should atheists have to prove that He doesn’t?  There are plenty of people who respond by pronouncing themselves “agnostic”: “I just don’t know.”

Fair enough – unless the question of God’s existence is as pressing and relevant as whether the volcano above my house will explode in the next 24 hours.  Since I’m not a volcanologist, I could legitimately say, “I just don’t know.” But it’s not as though the upshot of the debate is unimportant to my life and flourishing.  To proclaim myself “agnostic” – and then go back inside my house – is not a “neutral” response.  With my actions, I show that I am siding with those who claim that this isn’t a relevant concern.   …

Continue reading >>>>>>>