By John M. Grondelski, Ph.D., Catholic World Report, July 16, 2023
John M. Grondelski (Ph.D., Fordham) was former associate dean of the School of Theology, Seton Hall University, South Orange, New Jersey. He publishes regularly in the National Catholic Register and in theological journals. All views expressed herein are exclusively his own.
Pope St. John Paul II launched World Youth Day on the model of his own work as a university professor with young people, offering a clear and explicit Catholic vision, not excluding anybody but also not tailoring his message to “soften” its Catholic edges.
In the wake of the debacle over Cardinal-Designate Americo Aguiar’s remarks that World Youth Day (WYD) 2023 doesn’t intend to “convert” any youth because its goal was rather some kind of amorphous exercise in “fraternity,” somebody apparently sent out a “Lisbon, We Have a Problem” alert. The usual defensive mechanisms sprang into place: whenever a hierarch today utters something utterly off-the-wall, there follows efforts to walk back those off-the-wall remarks.
It started with Bishop Aguiar himself. He certainly never meant to suggest that WYD shouldn’t bring youth—even non-Catholic youth—to “God.” No, the head of WYD 2023 and auxiliary bishop of Lisbon hopes all young people have a positive “experience of God” there. …
Continue reading >>>>