Fr. Thomas G. Weinandy: Pope Francis and Schism Re-Visited

Live in the Moment Like the Little Flower, by Teresa Mull
October 2, 2023
Do Not Be Anxious: Prayerful Tips for Maintaining Peace and Trust in God When Worries Weigh Us Down, by Edward Sri
October 2, 2023

*Image: St. Peter Enthroned with St. John the Baptist and St. Paul by Cima da Conegliano, 1515-1516 [Pinacoteca Brera, Milan, Italy]

By Fr. Thomas G. Weinandy, OFM, Cap., The Catholic Thing, Oct. 2, 2023

Thomas G. Weinandy, OFM, a prolific writer and one of the most prominent living theologians, is a former member of the Vatican’s International Theological Commission. His newest book is the third volume of Jesus Becoming Jesus: A Theological Interpretation of the Gospel of John: The Book of Glory and the Passion and Resurrection Narratives.

Note: I am in Rome today and our regular contributor Fr. Gerald Murray will be joining us here shortly for a bit of a new wrinkle for us at The Catholic Thing. As some of you are already aware, there’s a TCT App now available for download – for free. All you need to do is go to wherever you get apps and install it. You will be able to access daily columns there and also, as the Synod on Synodality begins later this week, a series of podcasts I’ll be producing with Fr. Murray, Diane Montagna, Raymond Arroyo, and others that will provide you with the very best in both news and analysis, in as timely a way as we can manage. You can find an introductory video about this podcast series here.

Today’s column is also something special. Four years ago, Fr. Weinandy wrote “Pope Francis and Schism” for us and pointed out that if the Synod endorses departures from Catholic dogma, Francis would be unique in history as both pope and a kind of anti-pope. It’s worth going back to read it in its entirety. And he has some observations today about what has happened since he raised a series of warnings. Read carefully.  It’s going to be an interesting time in the Church over the next four weeks – and beyond. – Robert Royal

 

Much has happened since I first published my original article, “Pope Francis and Schism,” in The Catholic Thing on October 8, 2019. What has taken place in the intervening years has confirmed many of the points I made then.   Here, at Robert Royal’s request, I would like to revisit and expand upon several of them.

First, Pope Francis’ dislike for and criticisms of the Catholic Church in the United States have intensified.  As I noted in the earlier column, the American Catholic Church is the foremost critic of Francis’ often theologically ambiguous statements.  Over the past four years, as Francis’ ambiguities have proliferated, often given in mid-flight and off-the-cuff, so has criticism of his statements and ecclesial policies mounted. …